Scottish Fiscal and Economic Studies (ScotFES) - Submission to Smith Commission

Published: 6 November 2014
Author: David Eiser

The ScotFes submission to the Smith Commission

Desire to increase the tax and spending powers of the Scottish Parliament is often driven by an aim to improve the accountability of the parliament to the electorate. The submission discusses what might be meant by accountability in this context, and the extent to which different powers – and the way they are exercised – can be said to improve the accountability of the parliament. It also discusses the inevitable trade-offs between accountability and budgetary risks and uncertainty.

The submission argues that in a first best world, the Scottish Parliament’s revenue control would match its spending responsibilities, but that this is unlikely to be achievable because many taxes are not appropriate for devolution for practical, legal or institutional reasons. Therefore the advantages of tax devolution for Scotland (greater accountability) have to be weighed against the disadvantage for Scotland (the risk of a potentially less generous or more volatile budget in the longer-term) and the risk to the UK and Scotland that tax devolution might lead to tax competition that is in the interests of neither.

There may also be a case for devolving aspects of welfare spending to the Scottish Parliament, but this should be underpinned by a set of clear principles, consistently applied.The submission also argues that control over minimum wages would also increase the accountability of the Scottish Parliament.

Lessons for Scotland from the EU’s Enlargement to Central and Eastern Europe

Brexit, the Irish border and Coronavirus

Building Bridges?

Small States in the Modern World: Opportunities and Vulnerabilities

RT @commonslibrary: Looking for expert and impartial analysis on the impact of #COVID19? We’ve put all our #coronavirus briefings in one p…

8 hours ago

RT @UKandEU: It’s a mistake to think that parliament is just about making laws & holding votes. A lot of the time, its about having convers…

10 hours ago

RT @ja_sheldon: Our #ParliamentandBrexit piece on devolution and interparliamentary coordination is now online in blog form https://t.co/OO…

10 hours ago

RT @j_sijstermans: In its opposition to the Belgian emergency government, the Vlaams Belang continues to push against the cordon sanitaire…

10 hours ago