Analysing the Manifestos: No radical change required?

Published: 21 November 2019

This week, the Labour Party launched their manifesto for the 2019 General Election, pledging radical change. In it, they set out their social and economic programmes, and their plan for Brexit. However, engagement with the broader constitutional questions facing the United Kingdom was minimal. Constitutional issues were presented at the end, nested under a pledge to ‘Tackle Poverty and Inequality’. The party detailed plans to abolish the House of Lords, replacing it with a Senate of the Nations and Regions and hold a constitutional convention to address some of these thorny issues, proposals all present in previous manifestos. New was a proposal to reintroduce Regional Offices to England, but this seems unlikely to fulfil the ambitions of those advocating for a more direct form of English representation. Regarding the devolved governments, Labour outlined its commitments to restore the power-sharing government in Northern Ireland, revisit the funding allocated to Wales, and invest in Scotland. On a second independence referendum, the party remained vague, saying that a referendum and independence would not be in Scotland’s interests but failed to explicitly rule it out. A Section 30 order would not be granted in the early years of a Labour government. 

Labour seems uncertain when engaging in constitutional debates and their Scottish MPs, caught between the hyper-unionism of the Conservatives and renewed calls for independence made by the SNP, may suffer for it.

Continuity and consolidation?

Northern Ireland will never be the same again

The 'other Union': Indyref2 and the future of the UK

Will 2019 be like 1987, 2015 or 2017?

The English Question and Brexit

Is the Scottish party system in flux? @MalcH argues that #GeneralElectionResults2019 is the new norm. But there are…

4 hours ago

What does the #GeneralElection2019 result mean for #ScottishIndependence? CCC Fellow @Coree_Brown shares her though…

4 hours ago

"The results of the 2019 general election are a radical departure for Northern Ireland, and mark a fundamental tran…

6 hours ago

RT @mark_mclaughlin: "There is not going to be an independence referendum in 2021. "It takes a long time to set up a referendum..this is g…

7 hours ago